Investigate U.S. History & Write Counterarguments

U.S. History Investigations: Counterargument

What type of argument writing will students work on?

Five U.S. History investigations prepare students to write Counterarguments about historical or social issues in speeches and letters to contemporary audiences. Counterargument tasks call for students to share claims, evidence, and reasoning in support of their position, as well as recognize and address challenging or conflicting arguments. Students draw on their earlier work with Critiques when they share their reasoning to critique, rebut, or reconcile possible counterarguments. The writing task sets a purpose for each investigation, whether trying to understand the perspective of people in the past in the Colonial Women, Presidency, and Abolitionism investigations or thinking about issues of representation in the Trail of Tears and Reconstruction investigations. Each investigation creates a process for social studies inquiry and writing across five days that begins with making connections to students’ lives and extending their incoming knowledge. Check out the Writing Progression page on our website to learn about the different styles of argument writing that are supported by RIW investigations.

Write Counterarguments: Students make an argument for an interpretation while recognizing and rebutting or responding to other possible interpretations. Students read sources and interpret them to argue for a position and rebut other views to counter the argument someone else might make.

Investigate U.S. History: Whether examining diverse women’s experiences in colonial North America, considering Black men and women who asserted their own conceptions of what it meant to be a “founder,” revising a trail marker to move beyond commemoration of the Trail of Tears to explain the systems and individuals responsible for it, or analyzing the different tactics and ideas of Black abolitionists, students investigate counternarratives that expand their understanding of our nation’s past and their connections to it.

How do I structure each investigation?

What's in an investigation?

Each investigation is designed around a compelling question, a text set of primary and secondary sources that offer multiple perspectives modified for reading level, and a writing task with a real-world audience and purpose. Materials for each investigation may include:

  • slides to guide instruction;
  • a detailed teacher guide;
  • a planning tool to support teacher decision-making;
  • a video of students’ thinking about the material;
  • a video overview of the investigation;
  • a student packet of materials;
  • sort cards to use in weighing the evidence;
  • audio files of us reading the sources aloud;
  • accommodated materials for bi/multilingual learners in English, Arabic, and Spanish.
  • samples of student writing scored using our argument writing rubrics;

We have learned from our partners that adjusting and adapting these curriculum materials to suit their context is important to supporting students’ learning with Read.Inquire.Write. Therefore, all of our files for use with students can be freely downloaded and edited with proper attribution (they may not be sold or used for profit).

One way to organize an investigation in the classroom

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. © 2021 Read.Inquire.Write. - University of Michigan - 48109 - readinquirewrite@umich.edu - This content can be re-used in other work as long as attribution is given to the authors: The Read.Inquire.Write. team at the University of Michigan. Indicate if the original was changed. You may not use the material for commercial purposes.

Login to View Downloads